Algernon Sydney Sullivan, born in Indiana in 1826, rose to success in New York City as a respected lawyer and a man who “reached out both hands in constant helpfulness” to others. After his death in 1887, the Society sought to honor him and the award bearing his name was established in 1925 by a Sullivan Memorial Committee and the New York Southern Society, which Sullivan had served as its first president. The award seeks to perpetuate the excellence of character and humanitarian service of Algernon Sydney Sullivan by recognizing and honoring such qualities in others. It was first presented in June 1925 at the George Peabody College for Teachers in Nashville, Tennessee, now a part of Vanderbilt University.
Mary Baldwin College presents the Algernon Sydney Sullivan award to the undergraduate senior woman who exhibit Sullivan’s ideals of heart, mind, and conduct as evidenced by a spirit of love for and helpfulness to others, who demonstrates "fine spiritual qualities, nobility of character – and unselfish service to the broad community." It is one of the highest honors that Mary Baldwin College bestows. An Algernon Sydney Sullivan Non-Student Award, recognizing unselfish service, noble character, and spritual qualities, may also be awarded.
| 1933 |
Abel McIver Fraser
Charlotte Alexander Taylor |
1934 |
William Wayt King
Grace Pilkington Crowe |
| 1935 |
Margaret Kable Russell
Charlotte Beverley Hoy |
1936 |
Margaret Elizabeth Pfohl
Mary Delia Nichols |
| 1937 |
Isabel McIlhenny Nichols |
1938 |
Nancy Witherspoon McFarland
Abbie Morrison McFarland
Jean Eaton Diescher |
| 1939 |
Hunter Bryson Blakely
Shirley Marvil Black
Frances Rosa Witz Hull (Mrs. Cordell Hull) |
1940 |
Nettie Lambuth DuBose Junkin
Hilda Elizabeth Brown |
| 1941 |
Passie Fenton Ottley (posthumously)
Louise Margaret Kinkel |
1942 |
Adelaide McSween |
| 1943 |
Mary Watters
Mary Rose Mitchener |
1944 |
Josephine Morton Hannah |
| 1945 |
Katherine Elizabeth Sherrill
Betty Lee Neisler |
1946 |
Lewis Wilson Jarman
Anne WIlson Armstrong |
| 1947 |
Emily Pancake Smith
Alice Parker Wilson |
1948 |
Lucille Foster McMillin
Irma Elinor Weathersby |
| 1949 |
Edmund Douglass Campbell
Cynthia Ann Betts |
1950 |
Josephine Baxter Timberlake
Frances Elizabeth Lankford |
| 1951 |
Alletta Wood Jervey |
1952 |
Florence Anderson Wimberly
Mary E. Lakenan |
| 1953 |
Libby Alby Bull
Jane Clay Tucker |
1954 |
Mary Ann Taylor
Frederick Lyons Brown |
| 1955 |
Mary Hornbarger Mustoe
Hope Summerell Chamberlain |
1956 |
Nancy Virginia Buston
Antoinette Rotan Peterson |
| 1957 |
Julianne Rand
Richard Randall Potter |
1958 |
Elizabeth Ann Withrow
Desiree L. Franklin |
| 1959 |
Carraleigh Ann Singletary
Elizabeth Camp Ebbott |
1960 |
Nina Elaine Vaughn
Ruth Carnegie Campbell |
| 1961 |
Mary Bruce Woods
Gilpin Willson, Jr. |
1962 |
Bertha Alicia Salinas
Eldon Defriece Wilson |
| 1963 |
Dorothea Louise Bessire
Archibald Alexander Sproul |
1964 |
Jacqueline Virginia Riddle
Katie Heard Craig |
| 1965 |
Charlotte Hoff Folk
John Baker Daffin |
1966 |
Karen Ann Cowsert
Margaret St. Clair Moore |
| 1967 |
Louise Stuart Tabb
Bessie Conway Lewis |
1968 |
Minna-Abbott Smith
Midlred Ellen Taylor |
| 1969 |
Judith Lynn Barnett
Charles Preston Lunsford, Sr. |
1970 |
Katherine Carr Crawford
Marguerite Hillhouse
James Trenholm Spilman |
| 1971 |
Herbert Snipes Turnes
Nancy Ruth Jones |
1972 |
Ruth McNeil
Lillian Carolyn Rudeseal
Patricia Catherine Click |
| 1973 |
Lilly Simrill Smith
Ella Jean Lewis |
1974 |
Ann Bowman Day
Bertie Murphy Deming |
| 1975 |
Constance Anne Bak
John P. Edmondson |
1976 |
Carol Lynn Howard
Jane Frances Smith |
| 1977 |
Donna Grey Booth
Diane Elizabeth Hepford
William White Sproul, Jr. |
1978 |
Nan Overton Mahone
Anne Kate Reid Hipp |
| 1979 |
Ellison Miller Carey |
1980 |
Mary Lynn Tuggle
Helen K. Groves |
| 1981 |
America de la Garza
George M. Cochran |
1982 |
Ann Belton Filipowicz
Paul O. Hirschbiel |
| 1983 |
Sandra Ellen Shufelt
Patricia Hoblert Menk |
1984 |
Vicki Denise Etheride
Staunton-Augusta Rescue Squad |
| 1985 |
Judith Ann Clegg
Elisabeth Kubler-Ross |
1986 |
Denise Corinne Ouellette
Martha Stackhouse Grafton |
| 1987 |
Jane Elizabeth Blair
Frank Robbins Pancake |
1988 |
Peggy Lynne Kellam
Marguerite F. Livy |
| 1989 |
Mary Kathleen Reagan
Katherine Dyer Dudley |
1990 |
Saunders Porteous Vickery
Ruth Peters Sproul |
| 1991 |
Elizabeth Lee Baker
Mabel Rackley Hirschbiel |
1992 |
Mary Virginia Cocke
Yoko Sakae |
| 1993 |
Evelyn Kate Mills
Lisa Kristine Nichols
Margaret Herscher Hitchman |
1994 |
Lori Lee Broglio
Amanda Jane Townes |
| 1995 |
Danica Jamison
Lucia Marie Morgan
Ouida Caldwell Davis |
1996 |
Maggie Marie Hagen
Sarah Jean O’Gorek
Dorothy Baughan Moore |
| 1997 |
Jennifer Ragan Dorough Fletcher Collins, Jr. Margaret Collins |
1998 |
Shannon LeNay Plaster
H. Gordon Smyth, Jr. |
| 1999 |
Crystal Scott-Whitlow
Margaret Pollard Rea |
2000 |
Christy Michelle Riggs
Rev. Dr. Billy Graham |
| 2001 |
Janeen Anita Pettus Carter
Georgeanne Bates Chapman |
2002 |
Kelly Michelle Wimmer
Alice Tolley Goodwin |
| 2003 |
Lin Lin Aung
Charles S. Luck III |
2004 |
Susannah Thornton Baskervill |
| 2005 |
Christian Brookx Peele
Elizabeth Kirkpatrick Doenges (posthumously) |
2006 |
Nzinga Salcedo-Hutchinson
Caroline Rose Hunt |
| 2007 |
Tiffany Jackson
YuLee Larner |
2008 |
Tromila Wheat
Mary Beth Smyth ’47 |
| 2009 |
Robyn Stegman
Louise McNamee ’70 |
2010 |
Erin Paschal
Patricia Hunt |
| 2011 |
Ada Sue Myers
Lee Cochran |
2012 |
Tierra Smith
Abigail Disney |